A few days ago, Nate Silver stated here the following:
“We see that Google searches for “health care” — although not a perfect proxy for media coverage — have spiked for about a week at a time, only to fall back down again. Which could reflect the media’s short attention span for the story, or the public’s.”
This got me thinking: what has been the relative interest in the current Republican health care attempt at health care? So I extended the time frame analyzed to be February 1, 2008, to July 6, 2017. I recreated the plot below in R using ggplot2 (and provide the code to create it at the end of the post).
The figure shows the relative interest in searching “health care” in Google over time. The x axis is the date. The y axis is the interest relative to the most popular time “health care” was searched. In this case it was when the March 2010. The scale goes from 0 to 100, where 0 is not as searched as relative to the most popular point. A 50 means that the term was only has as popular. 100 means that it was just as popular. We can discuss if this is a good or bad metric, but let’s table that for another time (since it’s a long discussion). In short, sometimes it’s good, others it’s bad.
The blue dot with a white triangle indicates the month where President Obama announced to a joint session of Congress he would actively pursue health care reform. The green dot with a white center dot indicates when Congress went on recess in August 2009. It was during this recess when a particularly large number of members of Congress first encountered the Tea Party. The blue dot with the cyan center indicates when the Affordable Care Act (ACA), aka Obamacare, passed in Congress. The green point with a white triangle is when the United States Supreme Court stated that the ACA was constitutional since its was considered a tax. The red and white point indicates when the House failed to pass health care reform in March 2017. The red dot and white triangle point indicates when the House passed the American Health Care Act (AHCA) to repeal and replace the ACA in May 2017.
I pointed out some of these events to give an idea of how popular searching “health care” was during some other events. Note that the popular moment for searching was when the ACA passed. However, what’s interesting is that people seemed much more engaged and interested in finding more about health care leading up to passing the ACA. This does not appear to be the case for GOP’s attempt at passing health care. Events that appear to be more similar in interest to the GOP’s attempts is when the Supreme Court revealed their judgement on the constitutionality of the ACA.
In short, this means that the public has been pretty disengaged with the GOP’s attempts at health care reform!
This raises a lot of interesting questions. Why is it that people appear less interested this time around? Here are three (possible) ideas I have:
- Health care is messy. Passing health care is complicated and confusing. People do not want to think about reworking the health care system again! (I’m not aware of data to support this claim. So it’s a complete shot in the dark.)
- There are a lot more distractions this time around. With contention between Trump and the media and recent missile tests from North Korea just to name two. (Again, can’t find data.)
- There’s simply too little information available for the public to easily digest on the GOP’s attempts at reforming health care. While the House’s bill is very unpopular according to Nate Silver, there is also a sizeable chunk on undecideds according to the YouGov poll. When the ACA was in the works, the process was long and time consuming. This attempt has been much faster (since it has come, died, and then been resurrected). This has prevented the public from really thinking about it. (Yay! Data!)
If you have any ideas (and/or data) to investigate this further, I’d love to hear about it! You can tweet it at me!
library(ggplot2)
dat<-read.csv(file="multiTimeline.csv", sep=",", header=FALSE) #note that I did remove the top of the csv file downloaded directly from Google
colnames(dat)<-c("Date", "Rel")
df<-as.data.frame(dat)
aca<- data.frame( Dat = "2010-03", Rel = 100 ) #when ACA was passed
oba<-data.frame(Dat = "2008-02", Rel = 29 ) #when Obama announced
#intention to pass health care
house1<-data.frame(Dat="2017-03", Rel = 32)#Rep House fails to vote on AHCA
house2<-data.frame(Dat="2017-05", Rel = 29)
sc<-data.frame(Dat="2012-06", Rel = 33) #SCOTUS decision on ACA and taxes
tea<-data.frame(Dat="2009-08", Rel = 57)# congress recess of aug 2009
mytheme<-theme(
plot.title = element_text(lineheight=1.5, size=35, face="bold"),
axis.text.x=element_text(size=23),
axis.text.y=element_text(size=23),
axis.title.x=element_text(size=28, face='bold'),
axis.title.y=element_text(size=28, face='bold'),
strip.background=element_rect(fill="gray80"),
panel.background=element_rect(fill="gray80"),
axis.text=element_text(colour="black")
)
#general setup
p<-ggplot(data=df, aes(x=Date, y=Rel, group=1))+geom_line()+
geom_point(data=df, aes( x=Date, y=Rel ))+
xlab("Date")+
ylab("Relative Interest")+
ggtitle("Realtive Interest in\nHealth Care Over Time ")+
theme(plot.title = element_text(hjust = 0.5) )
#important points
p<-p + geom_point(data=aca, aes(x=Dat, y=Rel), color="blue", size=4 )+
geom_point(data=aca, aes(x=Dat, y=Rel), color="cyan" )+
geom_point(data=oba, aes(x=Dat, y=Rel), color="blue", size=4 )+
geom_point(data=oba, aes(x=Dat, y=Rel), color="white", shape=17)+
geom_point(data=house1, aes(x=Dat, y=Rel), color="red", size=4 )+
geom_point(data=house1, aes(x=Dat, y=Rel), color="orange")+
geom_point(data=house2, aes(x=Dat, y=Rel), color="red", size=4)+
geom_point(data=house2, aes(x=Dat, y=Rel), color="white", shape=17)+
geom_point(data=sc, aes(x=Dat, y=Rel), color="forestgreen", size=4)+
geom_point(data=sc, aes(x=Dat, y=Rel), color="white", shape=17)+
geom_point(data=tea, aes(x=Dat, y=Rel), color="forestgreen", size=4)+
geom_point(data=tea, aes(x=Dat, y=Rel), color="white")
#adding general layout
p<- p + mytheme + scale_x_discrete(breaks = c("2009-01", "2011-01",
"2013-01", "2015-01", "2017-01"),
labels = c("2009", "2011",
"2013", "2015", "2017")
)
p
ggsave("rel_health.png")
